Red card or should be a yellow card for Kewell

khonthakek · Guru

Red card or should be a yellow card for Kewell

Date: Jun 20, 2010

I am in Australia and I do not really like socceroos very much but giving the redcord is a bid unjust because this ball to hand (he didnot intent to touch the ball). However, if we saw the prvious matches when a player meant to touch the ball or hand to ball, the referee just gave him only a yellow.

What about your opinions folks?

khonthakek · Guru

Anonymous wrote:

I am in Australia and I do not really like socceroos very much but giving the redcord is a bid unjust because this ball to hand (he didnot intent to touch the ball). However, if we saw the prvious matches when a player meant to touch the ball or hand to ball, the referee just gave him only a yellow.

What about your opinions folks?

Yes i do agree, the ref was very strict and i guess the australian fans were not satisfied with the ref?

Date: Jun 20, 2010

the ref has no choice. Harry Kewell was on the goal line. The ball was going into the net. He raised his arm. The correct call was made.

Date: Jun 20, 2010

khonthakek wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I am in Australia and I do not really like socceroos very much but giving the redcord is a bid unjust because this ball to hand (he didnot intent to touch the ball). However, if we saw the prvious matches when a player meant to touch the ball or hand to ball, the referee just gave him only a yellow.

What about your opinions folks?

Yes i do agree, the ref was very strict and i guess the australian fans were not satisfied with the ref?

u guys dont understand football... it was the right decision for the ref no matter wether it was on his intention or not... because he was broking the goal...

khonthakek · Guru

Anonymous wrote:

khonthakek wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I am in Australia and I do not really like socceroos very much but giving the redcord is a bid unjust because this ball to hand (he didnot intent to touch the ball). However, if we saw the prvious matches when a player meant to touch the ball or hand to ball, the referee just gave him only a yellow.

What about your opinions folks?

Yes i do agree, the ref was very strict and i guess the australian fans were not satisfied with the ref?

u guys dont understand football... it was the right decision for the ref no matter wether it was on his intention or not... because he was broking the goal...

you seem understand football more than anyone here right?? the ref was right to give a penalty , but ref should have given only a yellow card and penalty shoot out is enough for Gnana...and it 's fair for both team.

ed · Senior Member

Yes for penalty but no red card for sure, that was a hash dicision the ball hit his arm while he try to use his chest to block a ball a yellow and penalty would be justify.
Tim Cahill also was a victim of bad dicision from the ref on previous match against Germany.